Teams are Smiling, But are They Engaged

In today's competitive business environment, ensuring that our teams are engaged and satisfied is essential to the overall success of an organization. With higher employee engagement comes higher productivity, better customer service ratings, and less presenteeism and absenteeism. But how can we distinguish between employees who are genuinely happy and those who simply put on a fake smile at work? Let’s dive into understanding the difference between "nice" and "kind" workplace environments and how we can foster genuine engagement among our teams.

The "Nice Nod" Syndrome

I worked at an organization where culturally we just understood Minnesota nice - the concept of always keeping it pleasant. We've all seen it - the "nice nod" when someone is smiling, but not truly happy. This phenomenon often occurs in workplaces where employees fake their satisfaction to appease managers or maintain a facade of harmony. The discrepancy between a genuine smile and a fake one can be difficult to spot, especially when it comes to employee engagement. But ignoring this issue can lead to negative consequences for the company, such as high turnover rates, low morale, and reduced productivity.

To tackle this challenge, we need to identify the root causes behind the fake smiles and take action to create a more honest, genuine, and engaged work environment. So, how can we do this effectively?

Nice vs. Kind Workplaces

At first glance, "nice" and "kind" may seem synonymous. But when applied to workplace culture, there are significant differences between the two. In a "nice" workplace, employees may appear content on the surface, but deep down, they could be unhappy and disengaged. This can result from too much focus on maintaining appearances and not directly addressing employees' concerns or needs. Nice cultures shy away from having conversations where there are differences or may cause friction. Whereas kind cultures approach conversations directly as an opportunity to learn and grow and reach the optimal outcome.

A "kind" workplace nurtures genuine care, empathy, and understanding among team members. In this type of environment, employee well-being is prioritized, and open communication channels allow for honest dialogue about challenges and concerns. This encourages engagement and helps create harmonious teams that work together efficiently to meet their goals.

Here are some actionable tips to transform a "nice" workplace into a "kind" one.

1. Foster Open Communication

Encourage employees to openly articulate their thoughts and concerns. This can be achieved through regular check-ins, providing platforms for anonymous feedback, or creating safe spaces for employees to express their feelings. We normalize and embrace differing opinions and ideas as a way to build something better.

2. Prioritize Employee Well-being

Ensure that employees' mental and emotional well-being is a top priority. Make resources for mental health support readily available and promote a healthy work-life integration. Instead of determining what that means for your teams, ask them what they need for mental well-being and how you can facilitate better work-life integration. When you ask, employees will tell you what they need and conversely they will give you what you need.

3. Set Realistic Goals and Reward Success

Employees should feel motivated and challenged, but not overwhelmed. Set attainable milestones, and recognize and reward employees for their achievements. This will help reinforce their sense of contribution and accomplishment.

4. Lead by Example

As a people manager or leader, your attitude and behavior sets the tone and significantly impacts the overall culture within the workplace. Create a kind environment by demonstrating empathy, compassion, and integrity in your daily interactions. Hold yourself to the same standards you hold your team to. Check in with people individually, be present, listen with intention. Remember, there is nothing more important than motivating your people as a leader.

Creating a kind and engaged workplace is a continuous journey that requires ongoing efforts and commitment from leaders and employees alike. By fostering a transparent and empathetic work environment, we can transition away from the "nice nod" syndrome, peeling back those fake smiles and cultivating genuine happiness and satisfaction in the workplace.

hashtag#Leadership hashtag#HumanResources hashtag#ManagementConsulting hashtag#KindCulture

Not sure where to start?? Send us a DM today, we can help!